What I learned after watching three men’s groups die:
What I discovered was what I needed for the fourth group to succeed.
By: Armando Allen, National Director of Men’s Ministry, Hispanic Baptist Network
Before our men’s ministry was up and running, I first analyzed why three previous groups had failed.

The first group died because trust was broken. Someone shared something vulnerable on a Tuesday, and by Thursday, it had become a "prayer request" in the church group chat. It wasn’t an explosion; it was a whisper. But that was enough to ensure no one would ever open up again.
The second group died because it turned into a tribunal. Whenever someone shared a struggle, three or four voices would rush in with unsolicited advice. The men who most needed to talk were the first to fall silent.
The third group died of relational starvation. It was a good Bible study. But that was all it was. The men would come, learn, and leave. No one truly knew anyone else. It was like eating together without taking off your helmet.
Each failure taught me something different. But all three had one thing in common: it wasn’t a lack of good intentions. What was missing was structure, a clear framework defining what could and could not be expected. It was about having ground rules that created something no curriculum, video, or book could ever produce on its own: a sense of security. And without a sense of security, no man removes his mask.
Ecclesiastes 4:9-10, puts it in a way that seems written for men’s groups: “Two are better than one because they have a good reward for their efforts. For if either falls, his companion can lift him up; but pity the one who falls without another to lift him up” CSB. God never designed men to walk alone. But walking with others requires a space where it is safe to do so.
Jesus modeled this with His disciples. He did not seat them in rows to listen to lectures. He placed them in a circle where they ate together, confessed together, failed together, and were restored together. Christ’s model for transforming men was always relational, never institutional.
What I discovered is that when you establish clear agreements before you begin, not after the first problem arises, but beforehand, the atmosphere changes completely. Men start to speak honestly. Things they had kept inside for years find a voice for the first time. Stumbles are no longer the end. Grace ceases to be an abstract doctrine and becomes something that is lived out within the group.
You do not need anything sophisticated. You need a few rules, but firm ones. Rules that protect trust, prioritize grace over judgment, and teach men to listen before trying to fix things.
Since we implemented that structure, I have seen men cry for the first time in decades. I have seen marriages that were in intensive care find a breath of air. I have seen fathers reconnect with children they had already given up for lost. Not because of some spectacular program but because of a safe space with clear rules.
If you are thinking about starting or reviving a men’s group in your church, at your workplace, or in your neighborhood, my advice after years of trying, would be this: don’t start with the curriculum. Start with the ground rules. Because even the best teachings in the world won’t work if men don’t feel safe enough to be real.
What would happen if the men around you had a place like this? Not just another meeting, a place where they could truly be known.
It’s worth a try. And if you want to know exactly what those rules are and how to implement them step by step, that is precisely what I cover in The Code of Honor.





Comments